HUNTER & SPORT HORSE

 

Dressage Scoring Too Transparent? 
How modern technology is affecting dressage judges 
and the dressage community.


Reprinted with permission
July/August 2005

Photos:  
Images from the official video of the 
2002 Games in Jerez:


Farbenfroh's passage, with
scores beside him. 

Invasor's pirouette, also
with scores displayed. Jerez
marked one of the first widely
available transparent videos.
Dressage un Ltd. photos

Nadine Capellmann on Farbenfroh
shown scoring 8s and 9s for the
canter half-pass.

Ulla Salzgeber on Rusty (shown at
Jerez scoring two 10s for one-tempis)
might have placed differently at the 
2000 Olympic Games had the three-
rider rule been in effect. 

      Once upon a time, referees and judges made decisions based on split-second observations, without the benefit of videotape technology.  Then instant replay was invented.  Decisions of all kinds -- especially controversial calls -- could be examined under the microscope.  Did that basketball player actually put a toe beyond the foul line?  Which race horse's nose crossed the finish line first?  Had an ice skater's arm dropped slightly out of position during a spin?  Occasionally a referee or a judge squirmed as the spotlight illuminated a poor decision.  Generally, however, sports and sports players benefitted from advances in video technology.

     At the Games in Rome in 1960, every dressage performance was filmed.  It took two days for the three judges to arrive at a final score for the Grand Prix.  The judges were chosen from countries not competing -- Netherlands, France and Chile.  Eleven countries, with 17 riders competed in dressage, no country having more than two riders.  The Grand Prix test was ridden once by all competitors and the top five rode it a second time for the Individual Medals.  This is the only time that video has been used to aid, rather than simply record, dressage judging.

What is Transparent Video?

     The classical nature of dressage combines with its inherently artistic -- and therefore, subjective -- aspect to discourage technological scrutiny.  Organizers of blockbuster sports such as football and soccer accept new technologies without a blink, focusing their energies on aggressive pursuit of TV coverage. Meanwhile, the relatively small world of dressage is still fighting to get basic airtime on cable. 

The advent of the transparent dressage video -- a video which shows the judges' marks movement by movement during the performances -- makes dressage understandable even for the non-dressage audience.  This is absolutely crucial if the discipline's competitions are ever to gain significant television appeal and large corporate sponsorships.  

continued on page 2

  Subscription Information
  Cover price: $4 per single issue
  Subscription: $21.95 per year, 6 issues per year

Subscription Orders:
  Call Toll Free:  1-800-554-7470
  Email Orders:  HSHHorse@aol.com
  Credit Card Online:  http://www.hunterandsporthorsemag.com

 

HUNTER & SPORT HORSE

Dressage un Ltd. | Dressage.com

Contact us: Email:  KyraBeth@Dressage.com
Fax: 918-234-1047
Snail Mail:  Dressage un Ltd., LLC

Box DUL, 1000 N. Lynn Lane Road
Catoosa, OK 74015-2611

Copyright © Dressage un Ltd.

All rights reserved.   Material from this website may be used only with written permission of Dressage un Ltd. and for non-commercial use only. 

Hit Counter